Score: 5

"Decent But..."

submission: Sonic X Chaotic Battle

date: July 11, 2003

Not bad, not great either. I know you put a lot of work into this but I was surprised by the amount of animation you copied from the intro to the Sonic game on Sega CD. Now that I think about it I wonder how much of this animation work was done entirely by you. I mean, the characters and backgrounds are so drastically different. It's like two entirely different skill levels. Oh well, viewing and being inspired by other people's work can only make you better. I wish you luck on your next project.

Score: 2

"Ummm... Okay."

submission: AnotherSkatingMovie FULL

date: February 5, 2001

I liked the fact that you animated the skater, not just some static 2-d image rotating in mid-air. I would like to see you carry this out more. Give it music and more detail, maybe even color? Do something to separate yourself from every other skate movie out there.